My initial response to this video by social-media guru Erik
Qualman is discomfort.
Anybody want to guess my age?
Though I do see and realize the benefits of social media, I
feel that we are becoming addicted to social media, spending more time online
in a virtual self-absorbed existence and less time face to face in
relationships with real people.
Example of good: A
person uses Facebook to appeal to others on behalf of a co-worker, whose
mother’s house burned down. This girl—a
college student, needed help because she was taking in her three young siblings
while her mother was going through the process of applying for Red Cross
assistance. Because of this appeal using
social media, this girl received donations of clothing and money...from near
and far...to help her during this difficult time. Social media=good.
Example of bad: One in five divorces are blamed on Facebook.
Surely we have enough assault on marriage, and now people are using
social media to arrange for cheating on their spouses? Nice.
Another bothersome fact:
69% of parents are “friends” with their children on social media. I’m not sure that I want my children using
social media. It can be very
dangerous to a teenager--you know, those precious creatures whose brains are not yet fully developed. On the other hand, if and
when my kids do use social media, I will stalk them “till the cows come home.”
The icing on the cake of what I don’t like is this: It is a sad state of affairs when Lady Gaga,
Justin Bieber, and Katy Perry—those “models” of humility and selflessness that
I want for my kids to emulate (that was a joke)-- have more followers on
Twitter than the populations of six countries combined. This is mind-boggling and maddening all at
once. Of course, in all fairness I can’t
blame this solely upon the existence and prevalence of social media. The problem goes much deeper...as in the
dangers of parents not parenting their children properly so that they won’t
have access to examples of how to have a selfish and destructive
existence. As a mother, it bothers me
when kids look to celebrities as their role models. If
we can use social media in a limited and productive manner, like pointing kids
to life instead of destruction, I’m all for it.
But social media promotes madness as well. Momma is uncomfortable.
Then arises that nagging suspicion: that those whose principles are not aligned
with what is “popular” might become “blacklisted” or unwelcome on social media
platforms because their beliefs are viewed as “intolerant.” In actuality, would it not be those who attempt
to quiet others who would in actuality be themselves the vessels of intolerant
behavior? Consider that Facebook has
already been known to favor some views over others. In January 2012, the social media site apologized
for censoring a post by a woman who gave girls instructions on how to self-induce
an abortion. The post was quickly
reinstated to her page. Less than two
months later, Facebook ordered
the removal of a graphic entitled “Abortionist” posted by a pro-life group,
a graphic intending to educate the public about what an abortionist actually
does during the course of his day-to-day work.
Apparently, tolerance is relative.
The growing pains have begun.
My point here is that I sense that perhaps not all are treated
equally as users of social media, and I’m concerned that social media has made
it easier for us to treat one another less than respectfully. In this “virtual” world of social media, much
like in the reality of a society whose god merely appears to be “fairness,”
some opinions are deemed more “correct” or “worthy” than others. I sense that the advent of social media has
served to “normalize” a disrespect for persons who do not agree with one’s own
worldview. It is much more difficult,
yet much more noble, to speak to someone face-to-face, than it is to “tweet” or
“message” a person using social media. It
seems as if the more “connected” we are via social media, the less “connected”
we are as social beings. Doesn’t science
tell us that we need real
relationships with real people in
order to thrive? How can we “drive”
social media so that it doesn’t become a vehicle for destruction and oppression
but instead contributes to our relationships and fosters civility and
productivity and dignity?
Don’t get me wrong—I’m not a “boycotter” of social
media. I use it daily. I just have serious concerns.
Ok. I got that all
out. Now will someone please comfort me
by explaining that the world will not come crashing down because of social
media? Momma needs some
reassurance.
Reference:
Qualman, E. (2012,
November 7). Social Media 2013|New Music.
Retrieved from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXD-Uqx6_Wk
No comments:
Post a Comment